Muslim Scholars Unfold Hadith Law Practices

Ad Feedback
Istanbul - Mehmet Kirbasoglu is passionate about his faith in Allah, the Muslim God. But he believes that his religion needs a fresh interpretation for the 21st Century.
"We need a new way of looking at our holy scriptures in the light of today's social and religious environment," Mehmet Kirbasoglu said.
And so for the past few years, Kirbasoglu, and 80 other Muslim Turkish scholars, have been examining the Hadith-- a collection of some 170 thousand sayings attributed to the prophet Mohammed. 
The Hadith is the second most sacred text in Islam after the Koran. It is also the basis of all Islamic Sharia law.
The Hadith includes some of the more controversial tenents, such as stoning adulterers, honor killings, female genital mutilation and amputation. The scholars will publish six volumes later this year that will throw out or re-interpret thousands of such practices.
"These and many other laws in the Hadith are very problematic for us today," Kirbasoglu said. "In the seventh century, life in the Middle East during the time of the prophet was very different. Some of these sayings and teachings need to be looked at in that historical context."
Nahide Bozkurt, a leading Islamic historian, has written extensively on the life of the prophet Mohammed. 
She concludes that many of the Hadiths were falsified, while others were made up to wield control over society.
"The majority of the Hadith is fabricated. As an historian, it is critical that the Hadith be researched extensively," Nahide Bozkurt, Islamic Historian said. "There has to be proof that the prophet actually said them."
She also rejects a literalist reading of the Koran and Hadiths.
"For example, there are versus in the Koran that are about war. Such versus should not be taken literally today and applied to life in order to justify war," Bozkurt added.
The team is also rejecting most of the accounts that were written about or ascribed to the prophet hundreds of years after his death.
""The potential for human error is there so we have to check all the writings for verification," Bozkurt said. "The wrong ones should be separated from the real ones."
Turkey's government is sponsoring the project.
"Liberal Muslim thinkers have tried similar projects in the past," Kirbasoglu said. "But this is different. This is officially sanctioned by the Turkish government and those involved in the project are Islamic scholars."
Some analysts say what Turkey is attempting to do here in modernizing Islam is somewhat similar to the Christian Reformation.
Though, these scholars are quick to resist calling it an Islamic Reformation.
"Muslims don't like the word reformation, so instead we can call this a re-thinking or re-interpreting of the versus," Bozhurt said.
For Kirbasoglu it represents at least a beginning of something that could potentially impact how millions view their faith. And fundamentalist Islamic groups are not likely to approve.
"Yes, there are those who have criticized us for embarking on such a project, but that's expected with anything this bold. But at least it's a start," Kirbasoglu said.

*Originally broadcast May 27, 2009.

Log in or create an account to post a comment.  


Are you seeking answers in life? Are you hurting? Are you facing a difficult situation?

Find peace with God, discover more about God or send us your prayer request.

Call The 700 Club Prayer Center at 1 (800) 823-6053, 24 hours a day.

A caring friend will be there to pray with you in your time of need.

CBN News
George Thomas

George Thomas

CBN News Sr. Reporter

CBN News is a national/international, nonprofit news organization that provides programming 24 hours a day by cable, satellite and the Internet.