PG for thematic elements and language
October 8, 2004
Hilary Duff, Jason Ritter, John Corbett,
Oliver James, Rebecca De Mornay, David Keith
New Line Cinema
In providing movie reviews on our site, CBN.com is not endorsing or recommending films we review. Our goal is to provide Christians with information about the latest movies, both the good and the bad, so that our readers may make an informed decision as to whether or not films are appropriate for them and their families.
Raise Your Voice
By Phil Boatwright
The Movie Reporter
- Most films nowadays are made with an intended audience. Adolescent
males who enjoy seeing things souped up, blown up, or gobbled up are generally
those courted first by movie studios. But teen and preteen girls, once very
much neglected by Hollywood, have finally convinced the film industry that
they will buy just as much popcorn as their male counterparts. After the success
of Mean Girls, Lizzie McGuire: The Movie, and at least four
recent Cinderella rip-offs, producers are now confident that the “Tween
Girls Rule” genre is alive and well. So here’s another film with
them in mind.
Hilary Duff stars as Terri Fletcher, a small-town girl who aspires to a
big-time singing career. When a personal tragedy interrupts her steady life,
Terri defies her father’s wishes and secretly heads off to a Los Angeles
performing arts summer school. But the school brings a whole new set of challenges
for Terri, who suddenly finds herself part of a highly competitive program
in an intimidating new city. Though initially overwhelmed by her new surroundings,
Terri rises to the occasion with the help of some newfound friends, an encouraging
teacher, a first love, and faith.
Although I suspect anyone not into all things Duff may find it less than
satisfying, teenaged girls who have grown up with Lizzie McGuire will love
it. And why not? Young girls will either relate to the lead character’s
adolescent frustrations or want to relate to her charms (Miss Lizzie has not
only blossomed, she simply cannot be badly photographed).
A bit shallow for adults, but for its intended audience, the film successfully
addresses several poignant issues, including standing up for yourself and
drawing from a spiritual core when facing life’s realities. And while
the film is gratefully far from the likes of Thirteen, it is a touch
edgier than previous Hilary Duff efforts due to fact that the main character
deals with the guilt of her brother’s death and the deceiving of her
In the story, Terri (Hilary) must either go along with a sneaky plan formulated
by her aunt and mother in order to get into the prestigious academy, or give
up her dream and stay home with an overprotective father. Parents may initially
fear that this premise condones lying to authority figures. What we must realize,
however, is that without some conflict in a movie there would be no drama.
But Terri is not a wiseacre Ferris Bueller-type who takes pleasure in pulling
one over on bumbling parents. Rather, the character feels remorse throughout
the film for her deception and ultimately the truth is faced. What’s
more, the picture is actually addressing this moral issue. With any luck,
family members will be reminded of the importance of communication.
The most satisfying moments for this old fogy weren’t in the final
musical showdowns, but in the three or four subtle moments that reflected
the family’s spiritual direction. At least twice, we see Terri go to
church by herself; we even see her pray. (When’s the last time you saw
that in a film aimed at juveniles?) Other times we see her singing in choir
and rehearsing the "Hallelujah Chorus". Also she wears and clings
to a cross left to her by her beloved brother. (When asked why it’s
a Celtic cross, the director, a practicing Catholic, gave a concise explanation
by simply repeating his entire name -- Sean Patrick Michael McNamara.)
Although Ms. Duff’s voice is still paper-thin, the film is full of
lively and often joyous music, with positive lyrics – follow your heart
– don’t give up – I’ll be strong – believe in
The actors give bright, sincere performances, and though somewhat linear
and unsophisticated, Mr. McNamara’s direction is effective at keeping
the narrative from becoming maudlin or sugary while never condescending to
his intended audience. Add to that the fact that he has avoided the usual
crudity found in most youth-oriented flicks and you have a funny, family-friendly
As for its star, Ms. Duff is beginning to outgrow her Lizzie-isms, showing
signs of becoming a real actress. Having grown up on sound stages, Hilary
has become close friends with movie cameras. Indeed, she may be the most photogenic
child star since the young Elizabeth Taylor. She is a beauty and will no doubt
be a gorgeous woman in a few years. But all too often actresses become overly
conscious of their looks (especially when they’re only sixteen), which
can limit acting muscles. No acting career survives on cuteness alone. Sincerity
and truth are found under the skin. Therefore, if Ms. Duff’s management
wants her to survive a fickle positioning on Hollywood’s wobbly celebrity
rung, then its time to focus more on thespian skills than exploitive promoting.
Though she is fine in this film, I would suggest she actually attend a performing
As for the film – it’s terrific for teens and tweens.
Rating: PG -- Though I caught no harsh
or profane language other than a few minor expletives, the expression “Oh
my God” now a common euphemism among the young, is used frequently.
A male student gets drunk, but is chastised by the lead for his behavior.
One scene features a teen couple passionately kissing, then suddenly drops
out of camera, presumably to further their new-found feelings. This is not
the main couple. The lead is cautious and it is clear that she is not rushing
into a relationship. A lie is at the center of the film’s premise, but
it sets up the moral question. A car crash leads to the death of a family
member. The director handles this situation and all the material with discretion.
Phil Boatwright is the editor of The Movie Reporter. Review used by permission.
Go to Phil Boatwright's website at www.moviereporter.com
for details on how to have reviews of new films delivered directly to your e-mail
CBN IS HERE FOR YOU!
Are you seeking answers in life? Are you hurting?
Are you facing a difficult situation?
A caring friend will be there to pray with you in your time of need.