Weekly Standard senior writer Jonathan Last warns that unless we change our views about the value of raising children, America faces a bleak future.
Read Transcript
Pat: WE READ TODAY --
AT LEAST I READ TODAY --
THAT CHINA HAS NOW SURPASSED
THE UNITED STATES IN TERMS
OF TOTAL EXPORTS.
THE GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT
OF CHINA IS ABOUT
$7.2 TRILLION.
THE UNITE UNITED STATES IS
ABOUT $15 TRILLION.
SO WE'RE TWICE AS LARGE AN
ECONOMY, AND YET THEIR
EXPORTS ARE BIGGER THAN
OURS, NUMBER ONE IN THE
WORLD.
YOU SAY THE BIGGEST THREAT
FACING AMERICA IS CHINA.
ACCORDING TO OUR NEXT GUEST,
THE BIGGEST THREAT FACING
AMERICAN MAY NOT BE CHINA OR
TERRORISM OR ANY FOREIGN
COUNTRY, OR EVEN OUR
NATIONAL DEBT.
THE BIGGEST PROBLEM WE FACE,
HE SAYS, IS SOMETHING FROM
OUR OWN HOMES.
TAKE A LOOK.
FOR YEARS WE'VE BEEN
WARNED, THERE ARE ARE TOO
MANY PEOPLE IN THE WORLD.
THAT WE'RE RUNNING OUT OF
LAND, FOOD, AND EVERYTHING
ELSE NEEDED TO SUSTAIN AN
OVERPOPULATED PLANET.
BUT AUTHOR JONATHAN LEST
SAYS THE BIGGEST CRISIS
FACING THE UNITED STATES AND
THE WORLD IS JUST THE
OPPOSITE.
HE HAS WRITTEN THE BOOK
CALLED "WHAT TO EXPECT WHEN
NO ONE IS EXPECTING."
LEST SAYS THE GREATEST
THREAT TO LIFE IN AMERICA IS
US AND OUR COLLECTIVE
UNWILLINGNESS TO HAVE MORE
KIDS.
HE SAYS THAT UNLESS WE
CHANGE OUR VIEWS ABOUT THE
VALUE OF RAISING CHILDREN,
AMERICA FACES A BLEAK
FUTURE.
DISEASE, WAR, AND ECONOMIC
COLLAPSE ARE ALL ON THE
HORIZON AS THE FERTILITY
RATE PLUMMETS AND OUR
POPULATION DECLINES.
Pat: WELL, WE'VE GOT
THE AUTHOR OF AN INTRIGUING
BOOK, "WHAT TO EXPECT TO
WHEN NO ONE IS EXPECTING,
AMERICA'S COMING DEMOGRAPHIC
DISASTER."
JONATHAN LEST JOINS US FROM
WASHINGTON.
GOOD TO HAVE YOU.
I WAS INTERESTING IN READING
YOUR BOOK.
I WANT TO TAKE ISSUE IN ONE
THING, I'M A FATHER OF FOUR,
AND WHEN WE WERE HAVING
LITTLE CHILDREN GROWING UP,
IT WAS A REAL PLEASURE.
SURE, IT COSTS A LOT OF
MONEY, BUT YOU MAKE IT SOUND
ENORMOUSLY EXPENSIVE.
IF WE TOTAL UP ALL OF THE
COSTS INCLUDING COLLEGE AND
MISSING WAGES AND CHILD
CARE, IT COSTS THE AVERAGE
MIDDLE-CLASS COUPLE OVER A
MILLION DOLLARS TO RAISE A
CHILD.
IT IS LIKE BUYING FIVE
HOUSES ALL AT ONCE.
THIS COST HAS INCREASED A
LOT SINCE 1965.
THIS IS ONE OF THE REASONS
PEOPLE HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE TO
HAVE AS MANY CHILDREN AS
THEY WANT TO.
Pat: ALL RIGHT.
LET'S GO TO SOME FIGURES.
WHAT DO YOU HAVE TO HAVE TO
SUSTAIN THE POPULATION.
IS IT 2.1 BIRTHS PER
THOUSAND.
2.1 BIRTHS PER WOMAN, PER
LIFE.
Pat: PER WOMAN.
Reporter: THE AVERAGE
NEEDS TO HAVE 2.1 WOMEN OVER
YOUR LIFETIME TO KEEP THE
POPULATION STABLE.
WHAT DEMOGRAPHERS CALL THE
REPLACE RATE.
Pat: THERE WAS A
PSYCHOLOGIST IN NEW ENGLAND
WHO WAS PROMINENT, AND SHE
JUMPED ALL OVER ME AND SHE
SAID, MR MR. ROBERTS SEEMS
TO THINK THE WOMAN'S WOMB IS
A NATIONAL RESOURCE.
IS THAT WHAT YOU'RE SAYING?
NO, NOT AT ALL.
THE WORLD HAS CHANGED, AND A
LOT OF WOMEN AND MEN WHO DO
NOT WANT TO HAVE CHILDREN.
BUT ONE OF THE THINGS I
DISCOVERED WRITING THIS
BOOK, WHEN DEMOGRAPHERS TALK
ABOUT THE IDEAL AMOUNT THE
PEOPLE IN AMERICA WANT TO
HAVE.
AND IN AMERICA, THAT NUMBER
IS 2.5.
SO DESPITE ALL OF THE TALK
ABOUT MEN NOT WANTING THIS
AND WOMEN NOT WANTING THIS,
THE TRUTH IS AMERICANS STILL
WANT BIGGER FAMILIES, BUT
THEY HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE TO
HAVE THEM.
THE GAP BETWEEN OUR REAL
FERT-ELEC FERTILITY AND OUR
IDEAL FERTILITY EXPLAINS THE
GAP BETWEEN PEOPLE HAVING
THE FAMILIES THEY WANT.
Pat: JONATHAN, WHAT
WILL HAPPEN IF WE AS A
NATION DOES NOT KEEP THE
REPLACEMENT RATE GOING.
WHAT HAPPENS?
ALL SORTS OF BAD THINGS
HAPPEN, AND SOME ARE
OBVIOUS.
YOU WOULD EXPECT OUR
ENTITLEMENT PROGRAMS,
MEDICARE AND SOCIAL SECURITY
BECOME VERY DIFFICULT TO
MAINTAIN.
BECAUSE YOU HAVE TOO MANY
PEOPLE RETIRING AND NOT
ENOUGH YOUNGER WORKERS.
AND IT BECOMES VERY HARD TO
SUSTAIN A DYNAMIC ECONOMY.
THE CONSUMPTION SHIFTS
DOWNWARD.
INNOVATION DRIES UP, AND
CAPITAL POOLS BEGAN TO
SHIFT, BECAUSE HAVE HAVE
OLDER PEOPLE LOOKING TO USE
THEIR CAPITAL, AND NOT
ENOUGH YOUNGER PEOPLE.
AND THERE IS JUST THE
MONEY.
YOU'RE SHIFTING OUT YOUR
MONEY FROM THE PENTAGON OVER
TO THE SOCIAL SECURITY
OFFICE.
AND JUST IN TERMS OF HAVING
THE PEOPLE OF MILITARY AGE,
18 TO 24.
THERE AREN'T ENOUGH OF THEM
TO FIELD A MILITARY.
Pat: GIVE US SOME OF
THE HORROR STORIES.
EUROPE AND JAPAN.
THINK ABOUT JAPAN.
REMEMBER IN THE 1980s,
WHEN WE WERE GOING TO ALL
WORK FOR THE JAPANESE.
AND WE WERE TALKING ABOUT
HOW WE WERE GOING TO HAVE TO
TEACH ALL OF OUR KIDS IN THE
PUBLIC SCHOOLS HOW TO SPEAK
JAPANESE IF THEY WERE GOING
TO EARN A LIVING.
THE DEMOGRAPHERS WERE
WARNING THE JAPANESE PEOPLE
THEIR FERTILITY RATE WAS SO
LOW.
AND JAPAN WENT INTO THIS
ENORMOUS RECESSION.
THE JAPANESE CALLED IT THE
LOST DECADE, BUT IT IS STILL
GOING TODAY.
BOTH ECONOMISTS AND
DEMOGRAPHERS IN JAPAN SAY IT
IS ALL BECAUSE OF THEIR
FERTILITY RATE.
THEY WEREN'T ABLE TO SUSTAIN
THEIR HUMAN CAPITAL.
JAPAN IS GOING TO LOSE A
LITTLE MORE THAN 50% OF ITS
ENTIRE POPULATION IN THE
NEXT CENTURY.
Pat: WHY?
I WAS STATIONED IN JAPAN
DURING THE KOREAN WAR.
I DIDN'T SEE THE JAPANESE
PEOPLE UNWILLING TO HAVE SEX
WITH EACH OTHER.
WHAT'S THE DEAL?
WHY DON'T THEY WANT TO
HAVE BABIES?
PART OF IT IS
UNWILLINGNESS TO HAVE SEX.
THERE WAS A SURVEY A WHILE
AGO, AND BOYS BETWEEN 15 AND
19 THOUGHT EVEN THE IDEA OF
SEX WITH A WOMAN WAS
DISGUSTING TO THEM.
THIS IS THE FIRST COUNTRY IN
THE WORLD WHERE YOU HAVE
TEENAGED BOYS WHO THINK LIKE
THAT.
AND THE OTHER PART OF WHAT
HAPPENED IN JAPAN IS THEIR
MARRIAGE CULTURE HAS
SUFFERED.
THE RATES OF MARRIAGE IN
JAPAN HAS FALLEN DRAMATICSLY
OVE DRAMATICALLY OVER THE
PAST FEW YEARS AND DIVORCE
HAS RISEN.
Pat: 50 YEARS AGO,
EUROPE DOMINATED, AND IT
SLSHUNK, AND IS THAT THE
RESULT OF NOT HAVING
BABIES?
IT IS.
THEY'VE HAD LONG-STANDING
PLANS TO RAISE THEIR
FERTILITY RATE, AND THEY
HAVE SUCCEEDED A LITTLE, AND
WHAT HAS HELPED IS THE
MASSIVE AMOUNTS OF
IMMIGRATION FROM NORTHERN
AFRICA.
GERMANY IS ALREADYLIZING
ALREADY LOSING POPULATION.
THEY HAVE GONE FROM FIGURING
OUT HOW TO BUILD CITIES INTO
TURNING OUT HOW TO DOWN SIZE
THEIR CITIES, AND THEY NOW
STUDY HOW DO YOU TAKE OUT
CITY BLOCKS.
YOU HAVE PACKS OF WOLVES
RETURNING TO TOWNS IN EAST
GERMANY WHERE THEY HAVEN'T
BEEN IN 400 YEARS BECAUSE
THERE JUST ISN'T ENOUGH
PEOPLE AROUND TO GET TO STAY
OUT IN THE WOODS.
YOU CAN GENERALLY HAVE TWO
TYPES OF POLICIES.
YOU HAVE LIBERAL POLICIES,
LIKE IN FRANCE AND
SCANDINAVIA, WHICH SURROUND
STATE-RUN DAYCARE CENTERS TO
HELP MOTHERS WORK MORE.
AND YOU HAVE THINGS LIKE TAX
INCENTIVES, WHICH YOU SEE IN
SINGAPORE AND JAPAN.
AND THE TRUTH IS NEITHER OF
THEM HAVE BEEN PARTICULARLY
EFFECTIVE.
IT IS REALLY HARD RAISING A
CHILD.
IT IS REALLY HARD HAVING A
FAMILY.
THESE LITTLE INCENTIVES AND
NUDGES AREN'T GOING TO DO
IT.
FORGET THE GOVERNMENT, YOU
HAVE TO WORK ON CHANGING THE
CULTURE.
CHANGE OUR ATTITUDES TOWARDS
FAMILIES AND HELP THEM
REALIZE FAMILIES ARE
IMPORTANT.
THEY'RE IMPORTANT NOUT AND
IN THE FUTURE.
Pat: WE FOUND OUT THAT
RELIGIOUS BELIEF PLAYS A BIG
PART IN THIS.
YOU HAVE TO HAVE A BELIEF IN
A FUTURE.
YOU DIDN'T ADDRESS THAT VERY
MUCH IN YOUR BOOK, DID YOU?
OR DID YOU?
I DO.
I TALK ABOUT IT IN THE BOOK
BECAUSE IT IS FASCINATING.
DEMOGRAPHERS HAVE STUDIED
RELIGIOUS BELIEF AND IT'S
EFFECT ON FERTILITY.
THE CATHOLICS HAD MORE
BABIES IN GENERAL THAN THE
PROTESTANTS DID, AND THE
PROTESTANTS HAD MORE BABIES
THAN THE JEWS DID.
BEGINNING IN THE 1950S AND
1960S, THOUGH SECTARIAN
DIFFERENCES BEGAN TO SLIP.
AND NOW WE SEE THERE IS
ALMOST NO DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
THE RELIGIOUS SECT, BUT IN
THE RELIGIOUS PRACTICE.
IT IS NOT WHAT YOU BELIEVE
BUT HOW OFTEN YOU GO TO
CHURCHES.
IF YOU GO EVERY MONTH, YOUR
FERTILITY RATE IS HIGHER.
THE PEOPLE WITH THE HIGHEST
FERTILITY RATE ARE THE
PEOPLE WHO GO TO CHURCH
SERVICES ONCE A WEEK.
IT DOESN'T MATTER WHAT
RELIGION YOU ARE.
YOU CAN BE PROTESTANT,
CATHOLIC, JEW.
IF YOU SHOW UP AT CHURCH
EVERY WEEK, THAT'S WHAT IT
IS, BELIEVING IN SOMETHING
BIGGER THAN WE ARE RIGHT
HERE AND RIGHT NOW.
Pat: JONATHAN, THANK
YOU VERY MUCH.
HIS BOOK IS CALLED "WHAT TO
EXPECT WHEN NO ONE IS
EXPECTING."
IT IS VERY INTRIGUING.
I THINK YOU'LL FIND IT A
VERY GOOD READ.
YOU CAN GET IT WHERE BOOKS
ARE SOLD.
FOR THOSE OF YOU WHO ARE
EVANGELICALS, I WANT TO TELL
YOU THERE IS HOPE.
YOU CAN OUTBREED THOSE
OTHERS WHO DON'T AGREE WITH
YOU.
THE MUSLIMS ARE CERTAINLY
DOING IT.
THEY HAVE, LIKE, SEVEN KIDS
PER FAMILY.
Terry: THAT'S TRUE.
A LOT OF THOSE COUNTRIES IN
EUROPE --
Pat: I DON'T THINK IT
HAS WORKED IN IRELAND.
IT IS AN INTRIGUING THING.
HE GOES DOWN THE LIST OF THE
COUNTRIES, WHAT THEY'VE DONE
AND WASN'T DOESN'T WORK, AND
HE POINTS TO SINGAPORE WHO
DELIBERATELY TRIED TO KILL
THE BIRTH RATE AND IT HAS
HAD A DEVASTATING EFFECT.